Study Group 2


Nature Study Group Summary


xx = critique was given, -- = no critique necessary
NAME IN GREEN = image was uploaded by this photographer

Select a month, below, to reveal or hide its contents. To see all rounds at once, choose "Select all."
Open and then right click "save as" to DOWNLOAD A GREYSCALE TARGET 
NEW: Read Nature Rules Tips for assistance in interpreting PSA's suggestions for a great nature photo (accessed from left pane of this page).
    Show All / Hide All
  • September 2019 Round

    SEPTEMBER 2019 ROUND
    Group A and Dan C. reviews Group A | Group B and Rick C. reviews Group B | Group C and Tom S. reviews Group C

    FOR THE SEPTEMBER ROUND, CRITIQUES DUE BY THE 29TH PLEASE

    NEW: Read charts going left to right (across) - Names in green have submitted images for the round


    GROUP A - use review chart below

    GROUP A and Dan C. reviews Group A
    - GROUP A -  Argo (A) Bhattacharyya (A) Binney (A) Bricelj (A)  Chubb (A) Dalvi (A) Davis (A)
    Argo (A) na. . . . . . .
    Bhattacharyya (A) . na. . . . . .
    X Binney (A) xx xx na. xx xx xx xx
      Bricelj (A)  . . . .na . . .
    Chubb (A) .. . . . na. . .
    Dalvi (A) xx .na
     X Davis (A) xx xx xx xx xx xx na.


    GROUP B - use review chart below

    GROUP B and Rick C. reviews Group B
    - GROUP B -  Finocchio (B) Fisher (B) Hayes (B) Hill (B) Murray (B) Paley (B) Patten (B) Rosner (B)
    Finocchio (B) na
    Fisher (B) NOT PARTICIPATING IN SEPTEMBER
    X Hayes (B) xx . .na xx xx xx xx .
    Hill (B) . . .na . . . .
    Murray (B) . . . na . . .
    Paley (B) . . . . na   .
    Patten (B) . . . . . na .
    Rosner (B) NOT PARTICIPATING IN SEPTEMBER


    GROUP C - use review chart below


    GROUP C and Tom Savage reviews Group C
    - GROUP C -  Smiley (c) Springett (c) Stamer (c) Treadwell (c) Wallis (c) Warning (c) Yang (c) Zheng (c)
    Smiley (c) na . . . . . .
    Springett (c) xx na xx . . . .
    Stamer (c) . . .na . . . .
    X Treadwell (c) xx xx xx na . xx xx xx
    Wallis (c) NOT PARTICIPATING IN SEPTEMBER
    X Warning (c) xx xx xx xx . na xx xx
    Yang (c) . . . . . . na
    X Zheng (c) xx xx xx xx . xx xx na


  • August 2019 Round

    AUGUST 2019 ROUND
    Group A and Dan C. reviews Group C | Group B and Rick C. reviews Group A | Group C and Tom S. reviews Group B

    FOR THE AUGUST ROUND, CRITIQUES DUE BY THE 29TH PLEASE

    NEW: Read charts going left to right (across) - Names in green have submitted images for the round


    GROUP A - use review chart below

    GROUP A and Dan C. reviews Group C
    - GROUP A -  Springett (c) Stamer (c) Treadwell (c) Wallis (c) Warning (c) Yang (c) Zheng (c)
    X Argo (A) xx xx xx xx xx xx
    X Bhattacharyya (A) xx xx xx xx xx xx
    X Binney (A) xx xx xx xx xx xx
    X Bricelj (A)  xx xx xx xx xx xx
    X Chubb (A) xx. xx xx xx xx xx
    Dalvi (A) NOT PARTICIPATING IN AUGUST
    X Davis (A) xx xx xx xx xx xx
    X Finocchio (A) xx xx xx xx xx xx
    Fisher (A) NOT PARTICIPATING IN AUGUST


    GROUP B - use review chart below

    GROUP B and Rick C. reviews Group A
    - GROUP B -  Argo (A) Bhattacharyya (A) Binney (A) Bricelj (A) Chubb (A) Dalvi (A) Davis (A) Finocchio (A) Fisher (A)
    X Hayes (B) xx xx xx xx xx xx xx
    X Hill (B) xx xx xx xx xx xx xx
    X Murray (B) xx xx xx xx xx xx xx
    X Paley (B) xx xx xx xx xx xx xx
    X Patten (B) xx xx xx xx xx xx xx
    X Rosner (B) xx xx xx xx xx xx xx
    X Smiley (B) xx xx xx xx xx xx xx


    GROUP C - use review chart below


    GROUP C and Tom Savage reviews Group B
    - GROUP C -  Hayes (B) Hill (B) Murray (B) Paley (B) Patten (B) Rosner (B) Smiley (B)
    Springett (c) xx xx REVIEWS NOT IN.
    X Stamer (c) xx xx xx xx xx xx xx
    X Treadwell (c) xx xx xx xx xx xx xx
    Wallis (c) NOT PARTICIPATING IN AUGUST
    X Warning (c) xx xx xx xx xx xx xx
    X Yang (c) xx xx xx xx xx xx xx
    X Zheng (c) xx xx xx xx xx xx xx


  • July 2019 Round
    JULY 2019 ROUND 
    Group A and Dan C. reviews Group B | Group B and Rick C. reviews Group C | Group C and Tom S. reviews Group A
    np = not participating - CRITIQUES DUE BY THE 24TH PLEASE
    Photo (pix) in? Study Group Member critiques written: (read downward)
    BY THE 14TH -A- -A- -A- -A- -A- -A- -A- -A- -B- -B- -B- -B- -B- -B- -B- -C- -C- -C- -C- -C- -C- -C- -C-
    - GROUP A -  Bha Bin Bri Chu Dal Dav Fin Fis Hay Hil Mur Pal Pat Ros Smi Spr Sta Tre Wal War Yan Zhe Zho
    Bhattacharyya  NA . . xx xx . . .na . . . . .. . . xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx
    Binney (A) . NA . xx xx . . .na . . . . .. . . xx xx xx xx xx XX xx xx
    Bricelj (A) . . NA xx xx . . .na . . . . .. . . xx xx xx xx xx. XX xx xx
    Chubb (A) . . . NA xx . . .na . . . . . . . xx xx xx xx xx XX xx xx
    Dalvi (A) xx NA xx xx xx xx xx
    Davis (A) . . . xx xx NA . .na . . . . . . . xx xx xx xx xx XX xx xx
    Finocchio (A) . . . XX xx . NA .na . . . . . . . xx xx xx xx .xx XX xx xx
    Fisher (A) .na .na .na .na na. .na .na NA .na .na .na .na .na .na .na .na .na .na .na .na ..na .na na
    - GROUP B - Bha  Bin  Bri Chu Dal Dav Fin Fis Hay Hil Mur Pal Pat Ros Smi Spr Sta Tre Wal War Yan Zhe Zho
    Hayes (B) . xx xx xx .. xx xx .na NA . . . . . . xx . . .. . .
    Hill (B) . xx xx xx .. xx xx .na . NA . . . . . . xx . . .. . .
    Murray (B) . xx xx xx . xx xx .na . . NA . . . . xx . . ... . .
    Paley (B) . xx xx xx . xx xx .na NA xx . .
    Patten (B) .. xx xx xx .. xx xx ..na .. .. .. NA .. .. .. . xx .. .. .. . .
    Rosner (B) . xx xx xx . xx xx .na . . . . NA . . xx . . .. . .
    Smiley (C) . xx xx xx . xx xx .na . . . . . NA . . xx . . . . .
     - GROUP C - Bha  Bin  Bri Chu Dal Dav Fin Fis Hay Hil Mur Pal Pat Ros Smi Spr Sta Tre Wal War Yan Zhe Zho
    Springett (C) . . . . .. . . .na xx xx xx xx xx xx xx NA . xx . . . . xx
    Stamer (C) . . . . . . . .na xx xx xx xx xx xx xx . NA xx . . . . xx
    Treadwell (C) . . . . . . . .na xx xx xx xx xx xx xx . . NA . . . . xx
    Wallis (C) . . . . .. . . .na xx xx xx xx xx xx xx . . xx NA . . . xx
    Warning (C) . . . . . . . .na xx xx xx xx xx xx xx . . xx . NA . . xx
    Yang (C) . . . . . . . .na .xx xx xx xx xx xx xx . . . . . NA . xx
    Zheng (C) . . . . . . . .na xx xx xx xx xx xx xx . . xx . . . NA xx
    Zhou (C) . . . . . . . .na xx xx xx xx xx xx xx . . xx . . . . NA
  • June 2019 Round
    JUNE 2019 ROUND 
    Group A and Dan C. reviews Group A | Group B and Rick C. reviews Group B | Group C and Tom S. reviews Group C
    np = not participating - CRITIQUES DUE BY THE 24TH PLEASE
    Photo (pix) in? Study Group Member critiques written: (read downward)
     IMAGES DUE THE 14TH -A- -A- -A- -A- -A- -A- -B- -B- -B- -B- -B- -B- -C- -C- -C- -C- -C- -C- -C-
    - GROUP A -  PIX? Bha Bin Bri Dal Dav Fin Fis Hay Hil Mur Pat Ros Smi Spr Sta Tre Wal War Yan
    Bhattacharyya (A) YES NA xx xx xx xx xx . . . . .no . xx . . . . . .NO
    Binney (A) YES xx NA xx xx xx xx . . . . .no . xx . . . . . .NO
    Bricelj (A) YES xx xx NA xx xx xx . . . . .no . xx . . . . . .NO
    Dalvi (A) YES xx xx xx NA xx xx . . . . .no . xx . . . . .NO
    Davis (A) YES xx xx xx xx NA xx . . . . .no . xx . . . . . .NO
    Finocchio (A) YES xx xx xx xx xx NA . . . . .no . xx . . . . . .NO
    - GROUP B - Bha  Bin  Bri Dal Dav Fin Fis Hay Hil Mur Pat Ros Smi Spr Sta Tre Wal War Yan
    Fisher (B) YES . . . xx . . NA xx xx xx .no xx . . . . .NO
    Hayes (B) YES . . . xx . . xx NA xx xxxx .no xx . . . . . .NO
    Hill (B) YES . . . xx . . xx xx NA xx .no xx . . . . . . .NO
    Murray (B) YES . . . xx . . xx xx xx NA .no xx . . . . . ..NO
    Patten (B) NO .no .no .no .no .no no. .no .no .no .no NA .no .no .no no .no .no .no .NO
    Rosner (B) YES . . . xx . . xx xx xx xx .no NA . . . . . .NO
     - GROUP C - Bha  Bin  Bri Dal Dav Fin Fis Hay Hil Mur Pat Ros Smi Spr Sta Tre Wal War Yan
    Smiley (C) YES . . . . . . . . . . .no . NA xx xx xx xx xx .NO
    Springett (C) YES . . . . . . . . . . .no . xx NA xx xx xx xx .NO
    Stamer (C) YES . . . . . . . . . . .no . xx xx NA xx xx xx .NO
    Treadwell (C) YES . . . . . . . . . . .no . xx xx xx NA xx xx .NO
    Wallis (C) YES . . . . . . . . . . .no . xx xx xx xx NA xx .NO
    Warning (C) YES . . . . . . . . . . .no . xx xx xx xx xx NA .NO
    Yang (C) NO .NO .NO .NO .NO .NO .NO .NO .NO .NO .NO .NO .NO .NO NO. NO NO NO. NO. NA
  • May 2019 Round
    MAY 2019 ROUND 
    Group A and Dan C. reviews Group C | Group B and Rick C. reviews Group A | Group C and Tom S. reviews Group B
    np = not participating - CRITIQUES DUE BY THE 24TH PLEASE
    Photo (pix) in? Study Group Member critiques written: (read downward)
     IMAGES DUE THE 14TH -A- -A- -A- -A- -A- -A- -B- -B- -B- -B- -B- -B- -C- -C- -C- -C- -C- -C-
    - GROUP A -  PIX? Bha Bin Bri Dal Dav Fin Fis Hay Hil Mur Pat Ros Smi Spr Tre Wal War Yan
    Bhattacharyya (A) YES NA . . . . . xx xx .na xx xx xx .na . xx . . .
    Binney (A) YES . NA . . . . xx xx na. xx xx xx .na . xx . . .
    Bricelj (A) YES . . NA . . . xx xx .na xx xx xx .na . xx . . .
    Dalvi (A) YES . . . NA . . xx xx .na xx xx xx .na . xx . . .
    Davis (A) YES . . . . NA . xx xx .na xx xx xx .na . xx . . .
    Finocchio (A) YES . . . . . NA xx xx .na xx xx xx .na . xx . . .
    - GROUP B - Bha  Bin  Bri Dal Dav Fin Fis Hay Hil Mur Pat Ros Smi Spr Tre Wal War Yan
    Fisher (B) YES . . . xx . . NA . .na . . . .na xx xx xx xx xx
    Hayes (B) YES . . . xx . . . NA .na . . . .na xx xx xx xx xx
    Hill (B) NO .na .na .na .na .na .na na na NA .na .na na .na .na .na .na .na .na
    Murray (B) YES . . . xx . . . . .na NA . . .na xx xx xx xx .xx
    Patten (B) YES . . . xx . . . . .na . NA . .na xx xx xx xx xx
    Rosner (B) YES . . . xx . . . . .na . . NA .na xx xx xx xx xx
     - GROUP C - Bha  Bin  Bri Dal Dav Fin Fis Hay Hil Mur Pat Ros Smi Spr Tre Wal War Yan
    Smiley (C) NO na .na na. na. na. .na .na .na .na .na .na .na NA na. .na na. na. na.
    Springett (C) YES xx xx xx xx xx xx xx . .na . . . .na NA xx . . .
    Treadwell (C) YES xx xx xx xx xx xx . . .na . . . .na . NA . . .
    Wallis (C) YES xx xx xx xx xx xx . . .na . . . .na . xx NA . .
    Warning (C) YES xx xx xx xx xx xx . . .na . . . .na . xx . NA .
    Yang (C) YES xx xx xx xx xx xx . . .na . . . .na . xx . . NA