Study Group 2


Nature Study Group Summary


xx = critique was given, -- = no critique necessary
NAME IN GREEN = image was uploaded by this photographer

Select a month, below, to reveal or hide its contents. To see all rounds at once, choose "Select all."
Open and then right click "save as" to DOWNLOAD A GREYSCALE TARGET 
NEW: Read Nature Rules Tips for assistance in interpreting PSA's suggestions for a great nature photo (accessed from left pane of this page).

NEW: Read PSA's new policy on the Legal and Ethical use of Aerial Photography, including Drone Photography
    Show All / Hide All
  • October 2019 Round

    OCTOBER 2019 ROUND
    Group A and Dan C. reviews Group B | Group B and Rick C. reviews Group C | Group C and Tom S. reviews Group A

    FOR THE OCTOBER ROUND, CRITIQUES DUE BY THE 27TH PLEASE

    NEW: Read charts going left to right (across) - Names in green have submitted images for the round


    GROUP A - use review chart below

    GROUP A and Dan C. reviews Group B
    - GROUP A -  Davis (B) Finocchio (B) Fisher (B) Hayes (B) Hill (B) Murray (B) Paley (B) Rosner (B) Extras
    Argo (A) . . . . . .
    Bhattacharyya (A) . . . . . .
    Binney (A) . . . . . .
      Bricelj (A)  . . . . .. .
    Chubb (A) . . . . . .
    Dalvi (A) xx . . xx xx . Binney, Bricelj, Davis


    GROUP B - use review chart below

    GROUP B and Rick C. reviews Group C
    - GROUP B -  Patten (C) Springett (C) Treadwell (C) Wallis (C) Warning (C) Yang (C) Zheng (C)
    Davis (B)
    Finocchio (B) .
    Fisher (B) . .
    Hayes (B) NOT PARTICIPATING THIS MONTH
    Hill (B) . . . . . .
    Murray (B) . . . . . .
    Paley (B) . . . . . .


    GROUP C - use review chart below


    GROUP C and Tom Savage reviews Group A
    - GROUP C -  Argo (A) Bhattacharyya (A) Binney (A) Bricelj (A) Chubb (A) Dalvi (A) Davis (A) Additional 
    X Patten (C) xx xx xx xx xx xx xx
    Rosner NOT PARTICIPATING THIS MONTH
    Springett (c) . . . . . . .
    Treadwell (c) . . xx . . . xx Fisher,
    Wallis (c) . . . . . . .
    Warning (c) NOT PARTICIPATING THIS MONTH.
    Yang (c) NOT PARTICIPATING THIS MONTH
    Zheng (c) . . xx xx . . xx


  • September 2019 Round

    SEPTEMBER 2019 ROUND
    Group A and Dan C. reviews Group A | Group B and Rick C. reviews Group B | Group C and Tom S. reviews Group C

    FOR THE SEPTEMBER ROUND, CRITIQUES DUE BY THE 29TH PLEASE

    NEW: Read charts going left to right (across) - Names in green have submitted images for the round


    GROUP A - use review chart below

    GROUP A and Dan C. reviews Group A
    - GROUP A -  Argo (A) Bhattacharyya (A) Binney (A) Bricelj (A)  Chubb (A) Dalvi (A) Davis (A)
    X Argo (A) na. xx xx xx xx xx xx
    X Bhattacharyya (A) xx na. xx xx xx xx xx
    X Binney (A) xx xx na. xx xx xx xx
     X Bricelj (A)  xx xx xx .na xx. xx xx
    X Chubb (A) xx xx xx xx na. xx xx
    X Dalvi (A) xx xx xx xx xx .na xx
     X Davis (A) xx xx xx xx xx xx na.


    GROUP B - use review chart below

    GROUP B and Rick C. reviews Group B
    - GROUP B -  Finocchio (B) Fisher (B) Hayes (B) Hill (B) Murray (B) Paley (B) Patten (B) Rosner (B)
    X Finocchio (B) na xx xx xx xx xx
    Fisher (B) NOT PARTICIPATING IN SEPTEMBER
    X Hayes (B) xx . .na xx xx xx xx .
    X Hill (B) xx . xx .na xx xx xx .
    X Murray (B) xx . xx xx na xx xx .
    X Paley (B) xx . xx xx xx na  xx .
    X Patten (B) xx . xx xx xx xx na .
    Rosner (B) NOT PARTICIPATING IN SEPTEMBER


    GROUP C - use review chart below


    GROUP C and Tom Savage reviews Group C
    - GROUP C -  Smiley (c) Springett (c) Stamer (c) Treadwell (c) Wallis (c) Warning (c) Yang (c) Zheng (c)
    X Smiley (c) na xx xx xx . xx xx xx
    X Springett (c) xx na xx xx . xx xx xx
    Stamer (c) . . .na . . . .
    X Treadwell (c) xx xx xx na . xx xx xx
    Wallis (c) NOT PARTICIPATING IN SEPTEMBER
    X Warning (c) xx xx xx xx . na xx xx
    X Yang (c) xx xx xx xx . xx na xx
    X Zheng (c) xx xx xx xx . xx xx na


  • August 2019 Round

    AUGUST 2019 ROUND
    Group A and Dan C. reviews Group C | Group B and Rick C. reviews Group A | Group C and Tom S. reviews Group B

    FOR THE AUGUST ROUND, CRITIQUES DUE BY THE 29TH PLEASE

    NEW: Read charts going left to right (across) - Names in green have submitted images for the round


    GROUP A - use review chart below

    GROUP A and Dan C. reviews Group C
    - GROUP A -  Springett (c) Stamer (c) Treadwell (c) Wallis (c) Warning (c) Yang (c) Zheng (c)
    X Argo (A) xx xx xx xx xx xx
    X Bhattacharyya (A) xx xx xx xx xx xx
    X Binney (A) xx xx xx xx xx xx
    X Bricelj (A)  xx xx xx xx xx xx
    X Chubb (A) xx. xx xx xx xx xx
    Dalvi (A) NOT PARTICIPATING IN AUGUST
    X Davis (A) xx xx xx xx xx xx
    X Finocchio (A) xx xx xx xx xx xx
    Fisher (A) NOT PARTICIPATING IN AUGUST


    GROUP B - use review chart below

    GROUP B and Rick C. reviews Group A
    - GROUP B -  Argo (A) Bhattacharyya (A) Binney (A) Bricelj (A) Chubb (A) Dalvi (A) Davis (A) Finocchio (A) Fisher (A)
    X Hayes (B) xx xx xx xx xx xx xx
    X Hill (B) xx xx xx xx xx xx xx
    X Murray (B) xx xx xx xx xx xx xx
    X Paley (B) xx xx xx xx xx xx xx
    X Patten (B) xx xx xx xx xx xx xx
    X Rosner (B) xx xx xx xx xx xx xx
    X Smiley (B) xx xx xx xx xx xx xx


    GROUP C - use review chart below


    GROUP C and Tom Savage reviews Group B
    - GROUP C -  Hayes (B) Hill (B) Murray (B) Paley (B) Patten (B) Rosner (B) Smiley (B)
    Springett (c) xx xx REVIEWS NOT IN.
    X Stamer (c) xx xx xx xx xx xx xx
    X Treadwell (c) xx xx xx xx xx xx xx
    Wallis (c) NOT PARTICIPATING IN AUGUST
    X Warning (c) xx xx xx xx xx xx xx
    X Yang (c) xx xx xx xx xx xx xx
    X Zheng (c) xx xx xx xx xx xx xx


  • July 2019 Round
    JULY 2019 ROUND 
    Group A and Dan C. reviews Group B | Group B and Rick C. reviews Group C | Group C and Tom S. reviews Group A
    np = not participating - CRITIQUES DUE BY THE 24TH PLEASE
    Photo (pix) in? Study Group Member critiques written: (read downward)
    BY THE 14TH -A- -A- -A- -A- -A- -A- -A- -A- -B- -B- -B- -B- -B- -B- -B- -C- -C- -C- -C- -C- -C- -C- -C-
    - GROUP A -  Bha Bin Bri Chu Dal Dav Fin Fis Hay Hil Mur Pal Pat Ros Smi Spr Sta Tre Wal War Yan Zhe Zho
    Bhattacharyya  NA . . xx xx . . .na . . . . .. . . xx xx xx xx xx xx xx xx
    Binney (A) . NA . xx xx . . .na . . . . .. . . xx xx xx xx xx XX xx xx
    Bricelj (A) . . NA xx xx . . .na . . . . .. . . xx xx xx xx xx. XX xx xx
    Chubb (A) . . . NA xx . . .na . . . . . . . xx xx xx xx xx XX xx xx
    Dalvi (A) xx NA xx xx xx xx xx
    Davis (A) . . . xx xx NA . .na . . . . . . . xx xx xx xx xx XX xx xx
    Finocchio (A) . . . XX xx . NA .na . . . . . . . xx xx xx xx .xx XX xx xx
    Fisher (A) .na .na .na .na na. .na .na NA .na .na .na .na .na .na .na .na .na .na .na .na ..na .na na
    - GROUP B - Bha  Bin  Bri Chu Dal Dav Fin Fis Hay Hil Mur Pal Pat Ros Smi Spr Sta Tre Wal War Yan Zhe Zho
    Hayes (B) . xx xx xx .. xx xx .na NA . . . . . . xx . . .. . .
    Hill (B) . xx xx xx .. xx xx .na . NA . . . . . . xx . . .. . .
    Murray (B) . xx xx xx . xx xx .na . . NA . . . . xx . . ... . .
    Paley (B) . xx xx xx . xx xx .na NA xx . .
    Patten (B) .. xx xx xx .. xx xx ..na .. .. .. NA .. .. .. . xx .. .. .. . .
    Rosner (B) . xx xx xx . xx xx .na . . . . NA . . xx . . .. . .
    Smiley (C) . xx xx xx . xx xx .na . . . . . NA . . xx . . . . .
     - GROUP C - Bha  Bin  Bri Chu Dal Dav Fin Fis Hay Hil Mur Pal Pat Ros Smi Spr Sta Tre Wal War Yan Zhe Zho
    Springett (C) . . . . .. . . .na xx xx xx xx xx xx xx NA . xx . . . . xx
    Stamer (C) . . . . . . . .na xx xx xx xx xx xx xx . NA xx . . . . xx
    Treadwell (C) . . . . . . . .na xx xx xx xx xx xx xx . . NA . . . . xx
    Wallis (C) . . . . .. . . .na xx xx xx xx xx xx xx . . xx NA . . . xx
    Warning (C) . . . . . . . .na xx xx xx xx xx xx xx . . xx . NA . . xx
    Yang (C) . . . . . . . .na .xx xx xx xx xx xx xx . . . . . NA . xx
    Zheng (C) . . . . . . . .na xx xx xx xx xx xx xx . . xx . . . NA xx
    Zhou (C) . . . . . . . .na xx xx xx xx xx xx xx . . xx . . . . NA
  • June 2019 Round
    JUNE 2019 ROUND 
    Group A and Dan C. reviews Group A | Group B and Rick C. reviews Group B | Group C and Tom S. reviews Group C
    np = not participating - CRITIQUES DUE BY THE 24TH PLEASE
    Photo (pix) in? Study Group Member critiques written: (read downward)
     IMAGES DUE THE 14TH -A- -A- -A- -A- -A- -A- -B- -B- -B- -B- -B- -B- -C- -C- -C- -C- -C- -C- -C-
    - GROUP A -  PIX? Bha Bin Bri Dal Dav Fin Fis Hay Hil Mur Pat Ros Smi Spr Sta Tre Wal War Yan
    Bhattacharyya (A) YES NA xx xx xx xx xx . . . . .no . xx . . . . . .NO
    Binney (A) YES xx NA xx xx xx xx . . . . .no . xx . . . . . .NO
    Bricelj (A) YES xx xx NA xx xx xx . . . . .no . xx . . . . . .NO
    Dalvi (A) YES xx xx xx NA xx xx . . . . .no . xx . . . . .NO
    Davis (A) YES xx xx xx xx NA xx . . . . .no . xx . . . . . .NO
    Finocchio (A) YES xx xx xx xx xx NA . . . . .no . xx . . . . . .NO
    - GROUP B - Bha  Bin  Bri Dal Dav Fin Fis Hay Hil Mur Pat Ros Smi Spr Sta Tre Wal War Yan
    Fisher (B) YES . . . xx . . NA xx xx xx .no xx . . . . .NO
    Hayes (B) YES . . . xx . . xx NA xx xxxx .no xx . . . . . .NO
    Hill (B) YES . . . xx . . xx xx NA xx .no xx . . . . . . .NO
    Murray (B) YES . . . xx . . xx xx xx NA .no xx . . . . . ..NO
    Patten (B) NO .no .no .no .no .no no. .no .no .no .no NA .no .no .no no .no .no .no .NO
    Rosner (B) YES . . . xx . . xx xx xx xx .no NA . . . . . .NO
     - GROUP C - Bha  Bin  Bri Dal Dav Fin Fis Hay Hil Mur Pat Ros Smi Spr Sta Tre Wal War Yan
    Smiley (C) YES . . . . . . . . . . .no . NA xx xx xx xx xx .NO
    Springett (C) YES . . . . . . . . . . .no . xx NA xx xx xx xx .NO
    Stamer (C) YES . . . . . . . . . . .no . xx xx NA xx xx xx .NO
    Treadwell (C) YES . . . . . . . . . . .no . xx xx xx NA xx xx .NO
    Wallis (C) YES . . . . . . . . . . .no . xx xx xx xx NA xx .NO
    Warning (C) YES . . . . . . . . . . .no . xx xx xx xx xx NA .NO
    Yang (C) NO .NO .NO .NO .NO .NO .NO .NO .NO .NO .NO .NO .NO .NO NO. NO NO NO. NO. NA